CivicFM
Long Beach

· 10 items

City Council, Tuesday, November 17

What happened, from the recording. The hosts take it up in Long Beach's next episode.

This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.

What happened

City Council Tuesday, November 17

10 items

The recording · Agenda · Agenda · Agenda · Agenda

Roll call, moment of silence and Pledge of Allegiance

At the roll call, five members answered, Mary Zendejas (Councilwoman, First District), Cindy Allen (Councilwoman, Second District), Daryl Supernaw (Councilman, Fourth District), Megan Kerr (Councilwoman, Fifth District) and Tunua Thrash-Ntuk (Councilwoman, Eighth District), and the clerk said there was a quorum. Kristina Duggan (Councilmember, Third District), Suely Saro (Councilwoman, Sixth District), Roberto Uranga (Councilmember, Seventh District; Vice Mayor) and Joni Ricks-Oddie (Councilmember, Ninth District) were not called; Roberto Uranga (Councilmember, Seventh District; Vice Mayor) spoke later in the meeting, on item 25. Tunua Thrash-Ntuk (Councilwoman, Eighth District) then led a moment of silence noting that November is Prematurity Awareness Month, and the Pledge of Allegiance. 00:31:40

Write to the City Council about this

Consent calendar Item 1-21

Twenty routine items approved in a single vote without discussion, including district discretionary grants, emergency-preparedness grants, purchasing contracts, two Long Beach Airport leases, and a protest of a liquor license transfer for a steakhouse on East 2nd Street. When the chair called the consent calendar, items 1 through 21, the chair also said item 10, the restated bylaws of the Pacific Gateway Workforce Partnership, was being withdrawn. 01:19:25

  • Approve consent calendar items 1 through 21, with item 10 announced as withdrawn (mover and seconder not named). Result: passed. 01:20:07

Write to the City Council about this

Closed session report

The council had held a closed session at 4:30 p.m. before the meeting. There was nothing to report from it. 01:20:09

  • City staff reported that there was no report from the 4:30 closed session 01:20:12

Write to the City Council about this

Continuing the local emergency for Hurricane Marie damage and El Niño storms, with a coastal recovery update Item 25

Disaster recoveryEmergency preparednessClimate and sustainability

The council voted to keep in place the local emergency it proclaimed after Hurricane Marie damaged the Peninsula shoreline, boardwalk and bulkhead, and to keep reviewing it every 30 days through the 2026–2027 El Niño winter storm season (agenda). Staff gave a broad update. It covered repairs on the Peninsula and beach rebuilding, preparations for the record-level king tides expected over Thanksgiving weekend, and how the work is being paid for. Staff said the money comes from coastal (Tidelands) funds that can't be spent elsewhere, not from the general fund. 01:20:17

  • Continue the local emergency and keep a 30-day review period (mover and seconder not named). Result: passed. 01:50:49
  • Thomas Modica (City Manager) said Hurricane Marie in September was followed by Hurricane Rachel in October, which did substantial further damage to the boardwalk and to homes 01:21:30
  • Thomas Modica (City Manager) said the Alamitos Bay entrance channel dredging, which puts 415,000 cubic yards of sand on the beach, was sped up, is more than half done, and should finish by the end of November 01:22:33
  • Joshua Hickman (Public Works Director) said the Public Works boardwalk and bulkhead repair began in mid-October and should be done by February or March, with crews rushing the stretch from 66th to 68th ahead of next week's king tide 01:23:38
  • Joshua Hickman (Public Works Director) put the boardwalk and bulkhead repairs at about $4 million and the channel dredging project at $11.4 million, on budget and ahead of schedule 01:24:41
  • Joshua Hickman (Public Works Director) said the goal is a beach about 250 feet wide and about 10 feet above sea level from 62nd Place east toward 70th 01:25:44
  • Joshua Hickman (Public Works Director) said a separate sand backpassing project will move about 200,000 cubic yards of sand, wraps up this week, and costs $960,000 01:26:46
  • Joshua Hickman (Public Works Director) said the Coastal Commission issued an emergency permit for a low-profile rock revetment between 63rd and 67th Place costing $5 million to $7 million, and that staff are still weighing whether it is needed 01:27:48
  • Joshua Hickman (Public Works Director) described a possible joint project with the port to put about 500,000 cubic yards of dredged sediment on the beach, which would cost the city $3 million to $5 million, with the Harbor Commission to take it up November 23 01:28:54
  • Joshua Hickman (Public Works Director) said October's king tides ran about 18 inches above prediction and set a new record of over eight feet, and that next week's tides are expected to be similar 01:29:57
  • Joshua Hickman (Public Works Director) said the city now has 10 pumps citywide, four newly purchased plus rentals, where it normally rents three in a storm season 01:32:08
  • Joshua Hickman (Public Works Director) said seven properties are red-tagged and the first demolition permit was issued October 28 01:34:08
  • Joshua Hickman (Public Works Director) said about half of the 2,200 to 2,500 linear feet of Naples seawall needing sealant will be done before next week's king tide and the rest before December's, as a temporary fix 01:33:08
  • Joshua Hickman (Public Works Director) corrected the slide to say the lifeguard station at 72nd is not a sandbag site and sent residents to the Claremont beach lot instead 01:34:08
  • Thomas Modica (City Manager) stressed that the money being spent can be used only for coastal projects and does not come from the general fund 01:35:45
  • Thomas Modica (City Manager) said $12.5 million of budgeted Tidelands projects are untouched, while a $10.1 million emergency reserve is being drawn on now 01:35:45
  • Thomas Modica (City Manager) said high oil prices have brought roughly $13 million in extra Tidelands revenue this year, that some costs may qualify for state reimbursement, and that a specific funding plan is coming soon 01:36:53
  • Thomas Modica (City Manager) put current costs at about $9.5 million: about $3 million in emergency response, about $2.5 million expected over the winter, and $3.5 million to $4 million for the bulkhead 01:38:00
  • Thomas Modica (City Manager) said that because the beach has been rebuilt, the rock revetment will very likely not be needed, saving about $7 million, and that this is under review 01:38:00
  • Rex Richardson (Mayor) said the city should not have to draw down Tidelands emergency reserves every year or two to protect the coast, and needs a long-term plan 01:41:21
  • Rex Richardson (Mayor) called for a standing agreement with the port giving the city first claim on locally dredged material to rebuild the beach 01:42:23
  • Thomas Modica (City Manager) said the Peninsula was originally built from port sand in the 1920s and 1930s, and that the last damage on this scale was in 1939 01:43:48
  • Thomas Modica (City Manager) warned of heavy rain Thursday and said storm drains are not designed for more than three-quarters of an inch per hour 01:44:51
  • Rex Richardson (Mayor) said the city should press the state, once its January budget comes out, to let money already set aside for oil abandonment be used for coastal climate impacts 01:45:31
  • Megan Kerr (Councilwoman, Fifth District) asked staff to confirm where residents can find sandbag and storm information before Thursday's rain 01:46:45
  • City staff pointed residents to the city's emergency web page for sandbags, project updates and spending 01:47:16
  • Roberto Uranga (Councilmember, Seventh District; Vice Mayor) said, as a member of the Coastal Commission, that sea level rise means the city must look beyond beach nourishment to managed retreat 01:47:30
  • Roberto Uranga (Councilmember, Seventh District; Vice Mayor) argued that coastal property owners should scale back the size of their homes to keep the beach and protect their property values 01:48:30
  • Tunua Thrash-Ntuk (Councilwoman, Eighth District) said the city will likely need money beyond the Tidelands Fund and its other current sources to manage the beachfront over the coming decades 01:50:17

Write to the City Council about this

Emergency coastal development permit process (zoning and Local Coastal Program amendment) Item 22

Zoning and plansDisaster recovery

A public hearing on an emergency ordinance adding an emergency coastal development permit to the city's zoning code. The change lets the city handle, on an emergency basis, coastal permits that fall solely within its jurisdiction. Staff said the city's Local Coastal Program dates to 1980 and has no emergency permit procedure. The package also included a CEQA exemption finding and a resolution (file 26-56662) sending the matching Local Coastal Program amendment to the California Coastal Commission for certification. It affects Districts 1, 2 and 3 (agenda). 01:50:51

▶ Hear it Will emergency coastal permits mean more rocks and less beach? · 0:42

  • Find the amendments exempt from CEQA (same motion and second as the item; mover not named). Result: passed. 02:07:07
  • Declare the urgent need for an emergency ordinance. Result: passed. 02:07:19
  • Adopt the emergency ordinance, effective immediately, and give it a first reading as a regular ordinance. Result: passed. 02:07:27
  • Adopt the resolution authorizing submission of the Local Coastal Program amendment (LCPA26-003) to the Coastal Commission. Result: passed. 02:07:38
  • Christopher Koontz (Community Development Director) said the governor declared a state of emergency for El Niño and storms on September 21 and the city issued its local proclamation the same day 01:52:06
  • Christopher Koontz (Community Development Director) said the municipal code does not lay out how permits are issued during an emergency, so the change is a procedural cleanup 01:52:06
  • Christopher Koontz (Community Development Director) said permits are already being processed under the emergency and no one is waiting on this change 01:53:07
  • Christopher Koontz (Community Development Director) said the Coastal Commission gave the change a courtesy review and is scheduled to hear it in December, and that staff had received no comments on it 01:54:08
  • Tunua Thrash-Ntuk (Councilwoman, Eighth District) backed the change as a way to help homeowners and businesses rebuild quickly, and asked whether there is a similar emergency permit process for the rest of the city 02:02:45
  • Christopher Koontz (Community Development Director) said the rest of the city already has emergency rebuilding procedures, and that rebuilt structures must meet current standards 02:03:36
  • Christopher Koontz (Community Development Director) said emergency permit holders must later return to settle permanent repairs, which must comply with local goals and the Coastal Act, including public access 02:04:41
  • Cindy Allen (Councilwoman, Second District) supported the change and said the city must keep working with the Coastal Commission so its emergency response stays consistent with the Coastal Act 02:05:20
  • Cindy Allen (Councilwoman, Second District) said protecting the coastline also means protecting public access to the beaches 02:06:28

Write to the City Council about this

Emergency boardwalk and bulkhead repair contract raised to $8 million Item 30

Disaster recoveryStreets and public works

The council received and filed a $1,000,000 emergency contract with Power Engineering Construction Company of Alameda for boardwalk and bulkhead repairs on the Long Beach Peninsula and as-needed marine construction, running October 24, 2026 to October 24, 2027. It also authorized adding $7,000,000, for a new limit of $8,000,000 (agenda; the clerk read the $1 million and $8 million figures). The chair said there was no presentation because it is part of the same storm response. 02:07:41

  • Receive and file the contract and authorize the amendment raising it to $8,000,000 (mover and seconder not named). Result: passed. 02:08:26
  • Rex Richardson (Mayor) said there would be no presentation because the item belongs to the same storm response topic, and invited comments 02:08:13

Write to the City Council about this

Lifting the single job order project limit for storm emergency work Item 33

Contracts and purchasingDisaster recovery

An urgency ordinance that temporarily suspends the city's cap on the size of a single job order project, for projects needed to address the Hurricane Marie and El Niño emergency during the 2026–2027 storm season. It takes effect immediately and was also read the first time as a regular ordinance, to come back for final reading (agenda). 02:08:27

  • Declare the urgency of the ordinance (mover and seconder not named). Result: passed. 02:09:12
  • Declare the ordinance and read it the first time, laid over to the next regular meeting for final reading. Result: passed. 02:09:23

Write to the City Council about this

Shelter crisis declaration for a temporary winter shelter Item 28

Homelessness

A resolution letting the city manager declare a shelter crisis, which suspends local zoning and other rules, and pick and run one or more temporary shelter sites. The sites replace beds temporarily lost at the shelter at 702 West Anaheim Street, for one year starting December 1, 2026 (agenda). Staff said this year's site will be on the East Side, at the old Freedman's site on Spring Street. 02:09:27

▶ Hear it Where will this winter's temporary shelter go? · 1:01

  • Adopt the shelter crisis resolution and authorize temporary shelter sites (the chair asked for the maker of the motion and Tunua Thrash-Ntuk (Councilwoman, Eighth District) was then called on; seconder not named). Result: passed. 02:11:38
  • Rex Richardson (Mayor) said the council does this every year to open the winter shelter 02:09:48
  • Tunua Thrash-Ntuk (Councilwoman, Eighth District) asked staff to avoid concentrating shelters, and poverty, in particular neighborhoods when choosing sites 02:10:05
  • City staff said the shelter will be on the East Side at the old Freedman's site on Spring Street while the 702 Anaheim shelter is rehabilitated 02:10:58

Write to the City Council about this

Technology purchasing contract increases and $5 million network equipment financing Item 32

Government technologyBonds and debt

The council raised three technology purchasing contracts: GovConnection by $2,000,000 to $17,500,000, CDW Government by $2,000,000 to $3,687,500, and ODP Business Solutions by $1,000,000 to $5,364,250. It also authorized a $5,000,000 lease-purchase financing with Bank of America Public Capital Corp. for critical network equipment, to be repaid over seven years at an interest rate set when the agreement is signed (agenda; the clerk read the new limits and the $5 million). No council discussion. 02:11:40

  • Approve the contract amendments and the lease-purchase financing (moved and seconded; movers not named). Result: passed. 02:12:48

Write to the City Council about this

Announcements

Members announced upcoming community events, and the chair gave storm-preparation reminders. 02:12:58

  • Tunua Thrash-Ntuk (Councilwoman, Eighth District) announced a ribbon cutting for the new 51st Street Green Belt park on Saturday, November 21, around 10:30 a.m., at 167 De Forest Avenue, and a neighborhood cleanup Sunday, November 22, at Hart Elementary 02:13:07
  • Megan Kerr (Councilwoman, Fifth District) invited residents to a Thanksgiving food drive and car show on Sunday, November 22, packing food boxes for more than 600 families, and mentioned a Shakespeare company production and holiday markets 02:14:21
  • Rex Richardson (Mayor) urged residents to prepare for rain, announced a sandbag event Saturday at El Dorado Park and a shore up the shore event with neighborhood leaders on Monday 02:15:19

Write to the City Council about this

Public comment

  • The clerk reported 13 written comments: two on non-agenda matters, one each on consent items 3, 11 and 12, one each on items 22, 25, 29 (withdrawn), 31 (withdrawn), 33 and 34 (withdrawn), and two on item 32.
  • About 15 people spoke in the single general public comment period, in person and by phone. The clerk had announced 13 sign-ups.
  • About seven speakers attacked the new public comment rules, which took effect at this meeting under the council's SB 707 changes. Their complaints: one three-minute comment period covering all items, no general comment at the end, limits on silent expression and clapping, and a repeated automated rules announcement. One said they had sent the city a cease-and-desist letter over the silent-speech limits. Three speakers also complained that the meeting, posted for 4:30 p.m., started 40 to 45 minutes late; one said it was the second week running.
  • About four speakers called for a free Palestine and against ICE and Israel. Two opposed a weapons manufacturer's plans to build in the city; a third urged divestment from technology and defense firms, that manufacturer among them, and opposed Flock surveillance. Several of them also asked the city to protect Black workers. Several used profanity and harsh insults toward the council.
  • Two speakers raised the withdrawn item 29, the police military equipment report. One said police should have no military equipment; the other asked when the public engagement meeting AB 481 requires would be held, and cited purchases of impact munitions.
  • One speaker described police brutality and proposed new screening of officers for prejudice and corruption.
  • One speaker complained that the City Prosecutor's office and the mayor's office would not return their calls.
  • One speaker asked the council to stand with striking Starbucks workers and to boycott Starbucks until there is a union contract.
  • One speaker said both elevators at the Aquarium were out of service despite a promised November 6 completion, and tied that to the city's pace on strengthening the Long Beach Values Act.
  • One speaker urged the city to build ongoing mental health services into disaster preparedness and recovery.
  • One speaker questioned item 32. They objected to the use of piggyback purchasing on other governments' contracts under City Charter section 1802, called the item's descriptions of purchases vague, and objected to borrowing $5 million for network equipment.
  • One speaker asked that consent item 11 be pulled because the contract had grown about 50 percent, supported item 28, linked items 25 and 33 to the city's oil history, and asked the clerk to track public engagement under the new rules.
  • One speaker asked the city to look at how its hybrid work policy is being applied.
  • At the item 22 hearing, two speakers urged a long-term coastal strategy and nature-based solutions. One, a longtime coastal activist, worried that emergency permits could allow more riprap and sand berms that limit public access. The other pointed to the city's history with oil and asked for a plan for its finances.

What's next

  • The item 22 emergency coastal permit ordinance returns at the next regular meeting for final reading as a regular ordinance. Staff said the Coastal Commission is scheduled to hear the Local Coastal Program amendment in December.
  • The item 33 job order ordinance returns at the next regular meeting for final reading.
  • The local emergency stays under a 30-day review period (agenda), so it will come back for renewal.
  • Staff said they will soon return with a specific funding plan and appropriation adjustments for the coastal emergency work.
  • The Harbor Commission is to hear the port dredge-sand project on November 23. Staff planned to apply to the Coastal Commission this week for an emergency coastal development permit for it.
  • Staff are reviewing whether the $5 million to $7 million rock revetment is still needed.
  • The second half of the Naples seawall sealing is to be done before the December king tide.
  • King tides are expected over Thanksgiving weekend, and heavy rain Thursday. There is a sandbag event Saturday at El Dorado Park and a shore up the shore event Monday.
  • The shelter crisis lets the city run temporary shelter sites for one year from December 1, 2026 (agenda); staff said this winter's will be at the old Freedman's site on Spring Street.
  • The chair said all items withdrawn from this agenda will come back at the next council meeting in December.
  • The agenda lists a December 1, 2026 hearing on a zoning code and Local Coastal Program amendment for the Omnibus Housing Ordinance.
  • The chair said the city should revisit using oil abandonment funds for coastal impacts when the state budget is introduced in January.

Write to the City Council before its next meeting: cityclerk@longbeach.gov or its comment form

Every claim is checked against the recording and documents linked above. Report an error